Is magnetite and lodestone the same?
Is magnetite the same as lodestone? Not quite: lodestone is magnetite ore that is itself a permanent magnet. NASA’s thresholds and the pick-up rule, worked.
Not quite. Magnetite, Fe2+Fe3+2O4, hardness 5.5 to 6.5, is the mineral; lodestone is magnetite-bearing iron ore that is itself a permanent magnet. NASA’s 1976 study set the line at a coercive force of 100 to 350 oersted, against 1.8 for a magnetite crystal. Every magnetite is drawn to a magnet; only lodestone picks up iron unaided.
In short
- The verdict. Wasilewski, Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 15 (1977), abstract: “A lodestone is an iron ore that behaves as a permanent magnet.” The Cambridge Dictionary has “(a piece of) rock that contains a lot of iron and can therefore be used as a magnet”. geology.com’s magnetite and lodestone article (Hobart M. King) says some magnetite specimens “are automagnetized” and that “This form of magnetite” is known as lodestone. A script finds no lodestone row on the September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List.
- The pick-up rule. Drawn to a magnet means a ferromagnetic mineral, such as magnetite. Picking up iron by itself means lodestone. Wasilewski, NASA TM X-71145 (1976) warns that a hand magnet “is not sufficient”, since “a distinction cannot be made between magnetite and proto-lodestone material”, and that “only lodestone is capable of charging pointers by touch”.
- NASA’s thresholds, worked. Wasilewski’s lodestone ores have saturation magnetisation of 20 to 80 emu/g, at most 83.3% of about 96 for Fe3O4; coercive force of 100 to 350 oersted, 56 to 194 times the 1.8 of a magnetite crystal; and a remanence ratio above 0.1, against below 0.01 for that crystal. His strong lodestone, USNM 99484, worked from his Table 1, sits at 62.0 to 70.7 emu/g.
- Documented failure: not every magnet passes the list. One of the four 99484 pieces, specimen 062, has a coercivity ratio of 2.54, just outside the 2.0 to 2.5 band, which the paper allows for “magnetically anisotropic lodestones” up to 3.5. And some ore that met every intrinsic test was not a magnet until charged in the laboratory: the paper calls it proto-lodestone.
- Why it matters on a label. The species name is magnetite; lodestone describes what a piece does. NASA found the strongest lodestone it studied to be two spinel phases, one with a cell edge of 8.396 Å, magnetite’s, and one of 8.376 Å, maghemite; the cell comparison is on is magnetite a spinel. Uses of lodestone outside mineralogy are not covered here.
| Quantity | Lodestone-type ore (qualifies) | Ore that does not qualify | Magnetite crystal | 1 µm magnetite powder | Lodestone USNM 99484 (4 pieces) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Saturation magnetisation Is, emu/g | Above 20, below 80 (at most 83.3% of Fe3O4’s about 96) | Above 80 | — | — | 62.0–70.7, worked (65–74% of 96) |
| Saturation remanence Isr, emu/g | Above 5 | — | — | — | 12.09–16.97 |
| Coercive force Hc, oersted | 100 to 350 | — | 1.8 | not legible in the scan | 225–295 (125–164 × the crystal) |
| Remanence ratio RI = Isr/Is | Above 0.1; most above 0.14; the strongest 0.20 or more | 0.05 to about 0.01 | below 0.01 | 0.40 | 0.19–0.25 |
| Coercivity ratio RH = HR/Hc | 2.0 to 2.5; anisotropic lodestones to 3.5 | Above 4.0 | — | — | 2.07–2.54 (piece 062 at 2.54) |
| Natural remanence ÷ Isr | Quite large, many above 0.5 | 0.1 or less, to 0.01 | — | — | — |
| Behaves as | A permanent magnet once charged | Attracted, not a magnet | Attracted, not a magnet | A magnet once compacted and exposed to a field | A strong natural magnet |
Is magnetite the same as lodestone? What the sources define
Magnetite is a species; lodestone is a behaviour. The September 2026 IMA list has magnetite, Fe2+Fe3+2O4, status G, 1845, and no row containing the word lodestone, by script. The Handbook of Mineralogy magnetite sheet gives cubic, hardness 5.5 to 6.5, density 5.175, black, streak black, “Strongly magnetic”, and says nothing about lodestone; nor does any other cached sheet. So the definition has to come from elsewhere.
Three definitions, read together. Wasilewski, Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors 15 (1977), abstract: “A lodestone is an iron ore that behaves as a permanent magnet.” The Cambridge Dictionary: “(a piece of) rock that contains a lot of iron and can therefore be used as a magnet”. geology.com’s magnetite and lodestone article (Hobart M. King): “Normal magnetite is attracted to a magnet, but some specimens are automagnetized and have the ability to attract small pieces of iron”, and “This form of magnetite, known as ‘lodestone’” was the first encounter with magnetism. All three make lodestone a piece of iron-rich material that is a magnet; none makes it a separate mineral.
Even NASA found the word loose. Wasilewski, NASA TM X-71145 (1976) says that before his work “there has never been a definition of the lodestone”, and that lodestone “has been referred to as magnetite, magnetic magnetite etc.”, a usage he calls probably valid because magnetite “has been used so loosely in reference to natural magnetic iron ores”. That is why the honest answer is not quite rather than yes or no.
How do you tell lodestone from magnetite? The pick-up rule
The rule. Bring the piece to a paper clip or iron filings, not a magnet to the piece. Wasilewski: “The most obvious way to distinguish a lodestone is of course to directly test its permanent magnet properties by using it to pick up paper clips etc.” geology.com adds that lodestone “is usually covered with small particles of magnetite and other magnetic minerals”.
Why a magnet will not do. Every magnetite is attracted: USGS Open-File Report 99-529 calls it ferromagnetic, “strongly attracted to a magnet, like a piece of iron”, and Table 1 draws it at a best 0.01 A. NASA’s report: testing with a hand-held magnet “is not sufficient, as a distinction cannot be made between magnetite and proto-lodestone material”; only after that test may the proto-lodestone show “strong attractive properties of its own”. And “only lodestone is capable of charging pointers by touch”.
Documented limit. A piece that fails the pick-up test can still be proto-lodestone: Wasilewski’s samples ULMER and M13, “which are proto-lodestones as defined were not permanent magnets”, and “Application of a 4000 field produced strong magnets” (the unit is not printed). The rule identifies a lodestone; it cannot rule one out. The wider magnet questions are on which minerals are magnetic.
What makes a lodestone? NASA’s thresholds, worked
The measurements. Wasilewski ran hysteresis loops on about 30 massive magnetic iron ores, hematitic ores, taconite and magnetite crystals, in fields up to 12000 oersted. Ores that qualify as proto-lodestone have saturation magnetisation below 80 but above 20 emu/g, saturation remanence above 5 emu/g, coercive force of 100 up to 350 oersted, a coercivity ratio of 2.0 to 2.5 and a remanence ratio above 0.1. A magnetite crystal from Algiers measured 1.8 oersted and a remanence ratio below 0.01.
Worked. The 80 emu/g ceiling is 83.3% of Fe3O4’s “∼96 emu/gm”, a shortfall Wasilewski suggests reflects substitution of titanium, magnesium or aluminium, or oxidation, or both. The coercive force band is 56 to 194 times the crystal’s. For the four pieces of USNM 99484 in his Table 1, saturation magnetisation, Isr divided by RI, comes to 70.7, 62.0, 63.6 and 65.0 emu/g, inside the band; their coercive forces, 225 to 295 oersted, are 125 to 164 times the crystal’s.
Grain, not chemistry alone. The paper’s key contrast: “the critical factor is the effective particle size”. Compacted 1 µm magnetite powder reached a remanence ratio of 0.40 and could be made into a permanent magnet. Lodestone behaves as fine intergrowths under 10 µm even when the piece weighs kilograms; many of the lodestones carried significant titanium, and the strongest, 99484, had none but held two spinel phases, a = 8.396 Å, the magnetite edge on is magnetite a spinel, and 8.376 Å, identified as maghemite. On maghemite’s magnetism see is hematite magnetic.
How does lodestone become magnetic? The lightning hypothesis
A proposal, labelled as one. Wasilewski, NASA TM X-71145 (1976) argues that proto-lodestone ores “are then charged by lightning”: some ores were not magnets until charged “in a field greater than 1000 oersted”, natural remanence in lodestones is large, and old accounts place lodestones in “localized patches within massive ore bodies”. He also writes that “All of this evidence is circumstantial at present”. Wasilewski (1977) gives the mechanism as “either transient magnetic fields with lightning-discharge currents, or presently obscure aspects” of magnetisation. This page reports the hypothesis and does not adopt it.
History, briefly and attributed. geology.com says suspended pieces of lodestone served as the first magnetic compasses, in China “as early as 300 BC”; Wasilewski writes that around 1200 AD the Chinese tested lodestone strength with weighed iron, and that Peter Peregrinus in 1296 and William Gilbert in 1600 shaped lodestone spheres with poles. These are their statements, not ours.
On a label. Write magnetite as the species and lodestone as the behaviour, with the locality; see how to label and catalogue a mineral collection. No cached Handbook sheet ties lodestone to any locality, so this page names none. Uses of lodestone outside mineralogy are not covered here. More guides are in the collecting guides. We hold no catalogue and nothing here is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.