Practical guidance on buying, grading, cleaning and storing mineral specimens, and on the labels, provenance and condition questions that are worth asking.
Practical guidance for buying and keeping specimens. Thumbnails fit a box of about 2.5 cm, miniatures run 3-5 cm and cabinet pieces 8-13 cm. Most British material is 100 years old or more, so labels carry provenance and disclosed restoration is normal. Cleavage, not hardness, is what breaks a specimen in storage.

Thumbnail, miniature, cabinet: the size categories are dealer conventions rather than standards. Knowing the ranges stop…
Read →
Nearly all classic British material is old, and that makes the label part of the value and restoration a normal question…
Read →
Most damage to a collection happens in a drawer, not out in the field. What actually threatens specimens — humidity, lig…
Read →Locality, condition, crystal quality, colour and provenance, in roughly that order. Why no dealer can price fluorite by …
Read →Six tests you can run on a desk, in the order that eliminates the most possibilities fastest: habit, hardness, streak, c…
Read →Dealers, shows, auctions and online marketplaces each solve a different problem. What each one is good at, what it costs…
Read →Usually not, and that is not a brush-off. What separates a specimen with real value from a heavy stone, and how to check…
Read →Water and a soft brush handle most of it. Quartz will tolerate almost anything and a soft arsenate crystal will not, and…
Read →Lead, arsenic, mercury, asbestiform fibres and uranium — what is genuinely dangerous on a shelf, what is not, and the on…
Read →Why some minerals glow, why the lamp matters far more than the rock does, why shortwave at 254 nm will burn your eyes, a…
Read →Pyrite decay is a chemical reaction, not a disease. Above 60% relative humidity a pyrite specimen oxidises to sulphates …
Read →Realgar, amethyst, green fluorite and the ruby silvers change irreversibly on a lit shelf. Which species are at risk, an…
Read →Repair is normal in the mineral trade and undisclosed repair is not. A six-step inspection order, what raking light and …
Read →Access is not permission and permission is not consent. Who owns the minerals, what a landowner can grant, and where the…
Read →Two blue-green botryoidal zinc minerals from the same oxidised zones. Density separates them, acid settles it, hardness …
Read →Ex coll. is short for ex collectione, from the collection of. The abbreviations old labels use, and the three-part test …
Read →Double-box, 25 mm of soft padding on every face, and a gap that compresses. The packing order that survives a courier, a…
Read →Lab-grown chalcanthite, dyed howlite, aura quartz and glued clusters. What is manufactured, what is disclosed treatment,…
Read →Do nothing irreversible for 30 days. Photograph every specimen with its label, keep labels with their stones, and check …
Read →Fewer than 300 species carry uranium or thorium, and a label names most of them. Dust and radon matter more than direct …
Read →Four different faults produce a pale crust, and the humidity causing each is different. Below 35% dehydration, above 60%…
Read →Both are hardness 3.5 to 4 and their densities differ by only 0.20. No hand test separates them, because they form a con…
Read →The locality a species was first described from, and where its type material was collected. Not the best locality, the o…
Read →Mostly no. Longwave at 365 nm shows the least. Shortwave at 254 nm shows the most and needs eye protection. What each ba…
Read →Read the photographs before the description, and check the locality on the label. A UK dealer owes you 14 days to cancel…
Read →Ground hazards hurt collectors long before the chemistry does. Never enter a shaft or adit on an old orefield, and get p…
Read →Six routes, and the honest crossover between them. A 400-specimen collection sold piece by piece is about 167 hours of w…
Read →An open shelf exposes a specimen to roughly 4,380 lit hours a year; a cabinet opened weekly, about 9. That 500-to-1 rati…
Read →Five fields, one permanent number, three certainty states. The IMA list holds 6,239 valid species, so a name without its…
Read →Cleavage repeats, parting does not, fracture never repeats at all. Kyanite's two cleavages meet at 79 degrees; hema…
Read →A micromount is a specimen trimmed and mounted permanently in a small box to be viewed only under a microscope. It is a …
Read →Air at 55% and 20 degrees is at 91.6% when it cools to 12 degrees overnight. That is why an afternoon hygrometer reading…
Read →Self-collected asserts that a named person found the specimen at the named place. Four questions test it, and one of the…
Read →Sometimes, and the conditions are specific. A missing locality is permanent, so the question is whether you are buying s…
Read →Choose the size format before the species. One 120 by 30 cm shelf holds about 400 thumbnails or 16 cabinet specimens — a…
Read →Conservation guidance names clear polystyrene boxes, low-acid card trays, acid-free tissue and Plastazote. The enclosure…
Read →Soak in deionised water, change it daily, and let time do the work. Hard brushing and compressed air break crystals, and…
Read →We machine-read the September 2026 IMA list: 5,988 of 6,195 names end in -ite, about 96.7%. The rules governing mineral …
Read →A stereo microscope at 10x to 40x is the right instrument. Depth of field falls from 55 micrometres at 4x to 1 micrometr…
Read →Dye pools in fractures and pores rather than following growth zones. Check colour distribution under a lens first: the d…
Read →Eliminate rather than confirm. One drag on a streak plate disposes of hematite, goethite and magnetite, which between th…
Read →Test on the base, wipe the mark, and look again. Kyanite is hardness 5.5 along the blade and 7 across it, so direction m…
Read →Filtered 254 nm shortwave is the lamp that shows willemite, calcite and scheelite. Of 74 mineral species we checked, onl…
Read →Set a cabinet to 50 lux and the fading clock slows about threefold against 150 lux. A UV-free LED does not make amethyst…
Read →Fool's gold is usually pyrite, hardness 6 to 6.5, density 5.018. Gold is hardness 2.5 to 3 and density 19.3, so it …
Read →Seal for dust, ventilate for radon. Store uranium species in rigid lidded boxes inside a vented cabinet, and survey the …
Read →Thermal receipt paper goes blank entirely; felt tip and blue ballpoint fade in a lit cabinet within years. Photograph th…
Read →Ex-mine claims a specimen came out of the workings. For species the Handbook records as of post-mine formation, such as …
Read →Four disclosures make a specimen photograph honest: scale, axial light, the damage face, and unadjusted colour. Shoot th…
Read →Give a show 3 hours minimum and spend the first one buying nothing. The walk-through costs nothing, and it is the stage …
Read →Hardness separates turquoise from five of its six common substitutes and density from five. Faustite defeats both, and i…
Read →Weigh the specimen in air, then in water, and divide. The specimen must outweigh your scale's resolution by 150 tim…
Read →Of 108 mineral species we checked, 78 record a streak and exactly half are white. Only quartz, topaz, corundum and schor…
Read →Twinning is recorded for 69 of the 108 mineral species we checked but called common for only 27. It is a fluorite cube i…
Read →A pseudomorph is one mineral in the crystal shape of another. Of 109 reference sheets we read, just one mentions the wor…
Read →Autunite is 49% uranium by mass and it crumbles on its own. Dehydration to meta-autunite costs it 18% of its volume, and…
Read →Silver-coloured pyrite is usually marcasite, arsenopyrite or a surface film. A density ladder from 4.887 to 7.58 separat…
Read →An insurer pays on evidence, not on opinion. The four-document standard sets out what each specimen needs, and which spe…
Read →Of 109 mineral species this site covers, 57 cleave perfectly and only 15 do not. The specimen is usually weaker than the…
Read →Salt is the most-suggested way to clean pyrite and the one that guarantees decay. Chloride plus pyrite makes hygroscopic…
Read →Same formula, different species. Mohs cannot separate them — both 6 to 6.5 — but the Vickers number can: marcasite 915 t…
Read →Arsenopyrite is FeAsS — 46.01% arsenic by mass. It is stable on a shelf and the exposure route is preparation: sawing, g…
Read →Halite fails above 75.3% humidity, chalcanthite below 35% and pyrite above 60%. The only band that suits all three cryst…
Read →41 of the 109 species here are described as secondary or as forming in the oxidised zone. Most display material grew fro…
Read →Oxalic acid strips iron stain and attacks 43 of the 109 species here, which contain carbonate, lead or calcium. Read the…
Read →A torch lights 10 to 62 square centimetres at 20 cm; a 25 cm tube about 625. Coverage, not power, separates the two, and…
Read →Realgar is 70.03% arsenic by mass and hardness 1.5 to 2. The risk is not touching it: it turns itself into arsenic-rich …
Read →A gossan is the iron-stained leached cap over a weathered sulphide orebody. The word is on none of 158 species sheets in…
Read →Fluorite gave fluorescence its name and its Handbook sheet lists five emission colours, more than any other species. It …
Read →Malachite is 57.48% copper by mass, hardness 3.5 to 4 and a carbonate. A solid specimen is inert. Cutting, tumbling and …
Read →No. Magnesite is a carbonate at density 3.00, howlite a borosilicate at 2.53 to 2.59. Both are dyed blue and sold as tur…
Read →Peridot is gem-quality magnesium-rich olivine. Olivine itself is a series name, spanning forsterite at density 3.275 and…
Read →Fluorite is hardness 4 with perfect cleavage on four planes, so no direction of applied force lies more than 54.74 degre…
Read →Only 4 of 158 mineral sheets mention acid at all. The reference literature will not tell you what survives, so classify …
Read →Galena is PbS, 86.60% lead by mass, hardness 2.5 to 2.75, with perfect cubic cleavage. An intact crystal is the easy cas…
Read →Amazonite is green microcline, KAlSi3O8, 14.05% potassium. Natural potassium is 0.0117% potassium-40, so it is weakly ra…
Read →Smithsonite may fluoresce pale green or pale blue, its Handbook sheet says, naming no UV band. It is one of 12 such shee…
Read →Scapolite is a group, not a species. Both its sheets say it commonly fluoresces orange to bright yellow or red, LW or SW…
Read →No. Both are CaCO3, but aragonite is orthorhombic at density 2.95 and calcite hexagonal at 2.7102. On a 50 g piece that …
Read →Six steps, in order: cleavage flash, hardness 6 to 6.5, a near-90 degree angle, density under 2.8, striations, context. …
Read →The three tetrahedrite-group Handbook sheets record no magnetism. 5 of 176 sheets record any. If your specimen pulls a m…
Read →A crystal with natural faces at both ends, because neither end was attached as it grew. A growth habit, not a twin; 1 of…
Read →Of 176 Handbook of Mineralogy sheets, 5 record a magnetic property: magnetite, pyrrhotite, greenalite, pyrite and borax.…
Read →Zeolites are open tetrahedral frameworks holding loose water; the IMA accepted 82 in 1997. 9 of 176 Handbook sheets say …
Read →Botryoidal means shaped like a bunch of grapes: rounded masses, often fibrous inside. A habit, not a species; 25 of 176 …
Read →Baryte is barium sulphate, 58.84% barium, and does not easily dissolve, which is why ATSDR says it causes few harmful ef…
Read →No. Chrysocolla is a copper silicate, hardness about 2 to 4, density 1.93 to 2.4; turquoise is a copper aluminium phosph…
Read →No. Rhodochrosite is manganese carbonate, hardness 3.5 to 4; rhodonite is a manganese silicate at 5.5 to 6.5. Their dens…
Read →No. Larimar is the trade name of blue pectolite from the Dominican Republic. Both are hardness 4.5 to 5, but density spl…
Read →Hardness first: calcite is 3 and quartz 7, four Mohs points apart. Then rhomb cleavage against conchoidal fracture. Dens…
Read →Fluorite is hardness 4 with perfect cleavage on four planes. A flat, bright break on a specimen is cleavage; a rough one…
Read →Massive malachite is dull by nature, its Handbook sheet says. Otherwise: wear at hardness 3.5 to 4, acid on a carbonate,…
Read →Vivianite darkens, but its Handbook sheet says oxidation, not light. 7 of 176 sheets record a light response and viviani…
Read →Adamite may fluoresce and phosphoresce lemon-yellow under SW and LW UV, its Handbook sheet says. In a 1948 test 2 of 7 l…
Read →Sometimes. Peacock ore is a trade name for bornite and for acid-tarnished chalcopyrite. A fresh surface decides: brass-y…
Read →No. Celestite, IMA name celestine, is strontium sulphate, hardness 3 to 3.5, density 3.97; quartz is silica at 7 and 2.6…
Read →Cinnabar is mercury sulphide, HgS, 86.22% mercury by mass, hardness 2 to 2.5. The form changes the answer: solid, dust, …
Read →No. Dioptase is copper silicate, hardness 5, density 3.28 to 3.35, green streak; emerald is green beryl at 7.5 to 8 and …
Read →Selenite is gypsum, hardness 1.5 to 2, clear unless impurities colour it. On a specimen, yellow or black, flaking and ch…
Read →Selenite is gypsum, and a crystal dissolves slightly: 0.24 g per 100 ml of water at 25 °C. That is about 171 times calci…
Read →UK law defines asbestos as six named fibrous silicates. Scolecite, a zeolite of hardness 5 to 5.5, is not among them, th…
Read →Amethyst is quartz, hardness 7, a crystal coloured by iron that radiation altered. Strong light fades it; 400 to 500 °C …
Read →A fluorite crystal is hardness 4, density 3.175 to 3.184, cubic. Of 176 Handbook sheets only fluorite passes all three. …
Read →A malachite specimen has a density of 4.05, so a 20.00 g piece weighs 15.06 g in water; 3.6 is the floor. Then check the…
Read →No. A zeolite has an open framework of linked tetrahedra (IMA, 1997). Apophyllite is a group of six species that grows b…
Read →Not strictly. GIA calls moonstone orthoclase layered with albite; labradorite is a calcic plagioclase at density 2.68 to…
Read →A mineral is a natural, ordered solid of definite composition; a crystal is one grain with its own faces. Quartz is a mi…
Read →Amethyst is quartz, hardness 7, a crystal that reads 1.544 and 1.553 on a refractometer. Glass reads once and shows bubb…
Read →Real labradorite flashes from inside the stone at set angles, with straight-edged colour zones and hardness 6 to 6.5. La…
Read →Labradorite flashes only at certain angles to the light, and some has a near-black body colour. At hardness 6 to 6.5, du…
Read →No. Chrysocolla is a copper silicate, density 1.93 to 2.4; malachite a copper carbonate, density 4.05. They grow togethe…
Read →UK law names asbestos actinolite. HSE's analysts' guide lists plain actinolite as its non-asbestos analogue, s…
Read →Calcite may fluoresce red, blue, yellow and more under shortwave and longwave UV; it is the only one of 176 reference sh…
Read →No. Smithsonite is zinc carbonate, density 4.43; aragonite is calcium carbonate, 2.95. A 20 g piece weighs 15.49 g or 13…
Read →Not strongly. Its sheet records no magnetism; USGS pulled rhodochrosite at 0.10 to 0.60 amp, paramagnetic, where magneti…
Read →Real tourmaline looks darker down its length and gives two refractometer readings about 0.020 apart, near 1.62 to 1.67. …
Read →No. Quartz is SiO2; tourmaline is a boron ring silicate, 34 to 38% silica by mass. Both are hardness 7; quartz is striat…
Read →Black tourmaline is a crystal, density 3.18 to 3.22; obsidian is volcanic glass, usually 2.33 to 2.42. A 20 g piece read…
Read →Often. The fluorapatite sheet says it may fluoresce in UV. Manganese gives yellow, rare earths blue, white or pink (Modr…
Read →No. The galena sheet records no magnetism, and USGS found 9 of 9 galena samples unpulled at 1.70 amp. In a galena specim…
Read →A bright, curved break on clean pyrite is a knock: pyrite is brittle, hardness 6 to 6.5, with no good cleavage. Powder, …
Read →Real rhodonite is rose-pink, often black-veined, hardness 5.5 to 6.5, and a polished piece reads near 1.73 on a refracto…
Read →No. Rhodonite is a triclinic manganese silicate with two cleavages at 92.5 degrees. Garnets such as spessartine are cubi…
Read →A real pyrite specimen is a brass-yellow sulphide, hardness 6 to 6.5, streak greenish black. A solid 8 mm pyrite bead we…
Read →Quartz is a mineral species: SiO2, hardness 7, density 2.65. Eight IMA rows share the formula SiO2, and cultured quartz …
Read →Gypsum is a mineral species, CaSO4·2H2O, hardness 1.5 to 2. Calcined, it becomes plaster of Paris: the formula of the mi…
Read →Lapis lazuli is a rock: GIA calls it an aggregate of lazurite, calcite and pyrite. Lazurite is the mineral, hardness 5 t…
Read →Two iron phosphate species, same mines. Ludlamite crystals are green, hardness 3.5; vivianite is soft, 1.5 to 2, and oxi…
Read →Stannite is a steel-grey tin sulphide, hardness 4, with a blackish streak. Cassiterite is tin oxide, hardness 6 to 7, de…
Read →No. Stibnite's sheet records no magnetism, and USGS left 6 of 6 samples of this antimony sulphide unpulled at 1.70 …
Read →Real rhodochrosite, manganese carbonate, is pink to rose-red, hardness 3.5 to 4, and a 20 g piece weighs at least 14.12 …
Read →Real citrine is yellow quartz, hardness 7, refractive index 1.544 to 1.553, unlike topaz. GIA says most citrine sold is …
Read →Real aquamarine is blue beryl, the species of emerald: hardness 7.5 to 8, two refractometer readings under 1.60. Blue to…
Read →No: alexandrite is the colour-change variety of chrysoberyl, BeAl2O4, hardness 8.5. Every alexandrite is chrysoberyl, no…
Read →No. Fluorite is a mineral, CaF2, hardness 4; fluoride is the fluorine ion and its compounds. Fluorite is 48.67% fluorine…
Read →Siderite, FeCO3, is not magnetic like magnetite: USGS pulled 17 samples at 0.10 to 0.50 amp. Of 16 anhydrous carbonates,…
Read →A phantom crystal shows its own earlier faces, coated by another mineral and overgrown. The GIA same-axis test separates…
Read →Obsidian is not a mineral: it is natural volcanic glass with no crystal structure, typically 66 to 72% SiO2 by mass. The…
Read →Amber is not a mineral: GIA classes it as organic fossilised resin, amorphous, hardness 2 to 2.5, specific gravity 1.08.…
Read →No. Zircon is Zr(SiO4), hardness 7.5; diamond is carbon, hardness 10. Of 12 diamond names on a gem society list of false…
Read →No. Topaz is Al2SiO4F2, hardness 8; quartz is SiO2, hardness 7. Of nine topaz names on a gem society list of false names…
Read →Real garnet is cubic: one refractometer reading, 1.714 to 1.888 on GIA's range, hardness 6.5 to 7.5. Glass reads 1.…
Read →Topaz crystals are striated along their length and cleave across it; quartz is striated across. Hardness 8; readings 1.6…
Read →Arsenopyrite, FeAsS, is not magnetic like magnetite: its USGS best range is above 1.70 amp. Of 18 arsenic species tabled…
Read →Yes. Torbernite, a secondary copper uranyl phosphate, is radioactive on its Handbook sheet, and by mass it is 47.15% ura…
Read →How a mineral auction works for a specimen or a collection: consignment, reserve, the hammer, buyer’s premium on 100 uni…
Read →Sometimes: the Handbook says hemimorphite, a secondary zinc silicate, may fluoresce bluish under shortwave UV. Six of th…
Read →Yes: the Handbook records blue fluorescence under shortwave UV. Laurs et al. found blue crystals inert under longwave an…
Read →Sometimes: mimetite may fluoresce reddish yellow under LW or SW UV, its Handbook sheet says. Of the three Pb5(XO4)3Cl mi…
Read →Opal has an IMA row, SiO2·nH2O, status G. Its structure varies: of 236 opals X-rayed in a 2019 review, 67 were amorphous…
Read →Chalcedony is quartz with crystals too small to see: hardness 7, SG 2.55 to 2.91 (IGS), no IMA row. Mexican onyx is calc…
Read →Jade is two rocks, not one mineral: jadeite (hardness 6 to 7) and nephrite, a tremolite-actinolite amphibole. Quartz, ca…
Read →Real jade is jadeite (SG 3.34) or nephrite (2.95); over 13.98 g in water for 20 g fits jadeite. Quartz and prehnite pass…
Read →Prehnite is not a zeolite. Its IMA formula groups (Si3Al)O10, 2.5 oxygens per tetrahedral atom, as in muscovite; all 13 …
Read →Malachite is not magnetic like magnetite: USGS pulled 7 samples at 0.20 to 1.40 amp, moderately paramagnetic. Of 30 copp…
Read →Yes. Labradorite is plagioclase feldspar, An50 to An70, hardness 6 to 6.5. Worked from its Handbook analysis, San Marcos…
Read →No. Moonstone is a gem name, not an IMA species: GIA calls it orthoclase and albite in layers about 0.5 micron thick, ha…
Read →Yes. Spodumene, LiAlSi2O6, is a monoclinic pyroxene, hardness 6.5 to 7, the lone Li pyroxene of the 1988 IMA report. Vir…
Read →No. Sodalite is a mineral, density 2.27 to 2.33, white streak, no pyrite; lapis is a rock, GIA SG 2.50 to 3.00. In water…
Read →Yes: its Handbook sheet records bright red-orange fluorescence under LW and SW UV. In GIA tests all 16 sodalite stones g…
Read →Natrolite and scolecite crystals share hardness, cleavage and weight. Optics split them: natrolite below 1.50, straight …
Read →Serpentine is not jade to GIA: it is antigorite, lizardite or chrysotile, Mg3Si2O5(OH)4, hardness 2.5 to 3.5. New Zealan…
Read →To tell if opal is real, look side-on first: GIA shows a triplet by its seam. Gilson synthetic is opal made in a lab; pl…
Read →For collectors: look first, weigh second, then ask a lab. Three of five named lapis imitations weigh inside GIA’s range;…
Read →Fuchsite is mica: the IMA mica report files it under chromian muscovite, and the IMA list has no fuchsite row. The 10-to…
Read →Chrysoberyl is not a beryl: BeAl2O4, an oxide, against beryl’s Be3Al2(Si6O18). It has 1.41 times beryl’s BeO by mass, an…
Read →Tiger’s eye is quartz, hardness 7, tied to crocidolite, the blue asbestos UK law names. How its fibres sit is disputed. …
Read →