Is monazite a critical mineral?
Monazite, a rare-earth phosphate species, is not named on the US 2025, UK 2024 or EU 2024 critical lists. Its elements are: rare earths yes, thorium on none.
Not by name. None of three lists names monazite; they list its elements. The US final 2025 list (60 minerals, 7 November 2025) names cerium, lanthanum, neodymium, samarium, gadolinium and phosphate. The UK 2024 list has rare earths as one entity, and phosphorus; the EU 2024 Act, light and heavy rare earths and phosphate rock. Thorium is on none.
In short
- The distinction. A critical-minerals list is a list of commodities, mostly elements, not of mineral species. Monazite is a mineral: five IMA species, each a rare-earth phosphate X(PO4). The question is whether its elements are listed. By script over the three fetched texts, the word “monazite” appears 0 times in the US notice and the EU Act’s text, and once in the UK report, in a trade-code description of thorium ores.
- The three-list ledger. The Federal Register notice of 7 November 2025, Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals names all 12 rare-earth elements printed on the four Handbook monazite sheets, including the five that head the IMA formulas: cerium, lanthanum, neodymium, samarium and gadolinium. The EU Act’s Annex I names 7 of the 12 as magnet rare earths, lanthanum not among them. The UK list names none individually; it lists “Rare earth elements (REEs)” as one entity. Phosphorus is on all three: “phosphate” (US), “Phosphorus (P)” (UK), and “phosphate rock” and “phosphorus” (EU).
- Thorium: on none. Monazite is the world’s primary source of thorium, says the USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Thorium, and the Handbook analyses hold 0 to 14.30% of it by mass. Yet the US list does not include thorium, the UK assessment excluded it “due to lack of production and/or trade data”, and the EU Act does not list it. Uranium, at most 0.55% in the same analyses, is on the US list only. Radioactivity questions are routed to is my mineral radioactive and how to store radioactive mineral specimens; nothing here is health, safety or legal advice.
- Documented limit: the EU rare-earth split. Annex II lists “heavy rare earth elements” and “light rare earth elements”, but the text fetched for this page does not say which elements each covers. This page therefore does not place lanthanum or yttrium in either EU entry. EUR-Lex refused automated fetches, so the EU text quoted is the Council’s adopted text, PE-CONS 78/23. It matches a saved EUR-Lex print of Annex II item for item.
- Dates matter. The US list is “not a permanent list” and will be “updated not less than biannually”. The UK report says it “does not constitute government policy”. The EU Commission is empowered “to amend Annex II, Section 1, in order to update the list”. Read any answer here as of those dates: 7 November 2025, 28 November 2024 and 11 April 2024.
| Element or name | Where it is in monazite | US final 2025 list | UK 2024 critical list | EU 2024 Annex II (critical) | EU 2024 Annex I (strategic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| “Monazite” (the mineral) | The five IMA species | Not named | Not named; once in the report, in a thorium trade-code description | Not named | Not named |
| Cerium | Monazite-(Ce), Ce(PO4): 59.60% Ce | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Named (Ce) |
| Lanthanum | Monazite-(La), La(PO4) | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Not named |
| Neodymium | Monazite-(Nd), Nd(PO4) | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Named (Nd) |
| Samarium | Monazite-(Sm), Sm(PO4) | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Named (Sm) |
| Gadolinium | Monazite-(Gd), Gd(PO4) | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Named (Gd) |
| Praseodymium | Sheet analyses, e.g. 6.47% Pr2O3 (monazite-(Nd)) | Listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Named (Pr) |
| Yttrium | Sheet analysis, 1.29% Y2O3 (monazite-(Sm)) | Listed | Within REEs (lanthanoids plus Sc and Y) | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Not named |
| Dysprosium, holmium, terbium, ytterbium, lutetium | Sheet analyses (monazite-(Ce), monazite-(Sm)) | All five listed | Within “Rare earth elements (REEs)”, assessed as one entity | Only through the “light” and “heavy rare earth elements” entries; the fetched text does not say which elements each covers | Tb and Dy named; Ho, Yb, Lu not |
| Phosphorus | The PO4 of every formula | Listed as “phosphate” | Listed, “Phosphorus (P)”; phosphate rock included in P | Listed: “phosphate rock” and “phosphorus” | Not named |
| Thorium | Analyses: 0 to 14.30% by mass | Not listed | Excluded “due to lack of production and/or trade data” | Not listed | Not listed |
| Uranium | Analyses: up to 0.55% by mass | Listed | Assessed: non-critical | Not listed | Not listed |
Is monazite a critical mineral? The mineral and the list
Two different things. Monazite is a mineral name: the September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List has five monazite species, Ce(PO4), La(PO4), Nd(PO4), Sm(PO4) and Gd(PO4). The critical-minerals lists name commodities, chiefly elements. So the honest answer is two-part. Monazite is not on any of the three lists by name. Its rare-earth elements and its phosphorus are on all three, and its thorium is on none.
Why monazite is asked about. The USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Thorium says “The world’s primary source of thorium is the rare-earth and thorium phosphate mineral monazite”, produced “primarily for its rare-earth-element content”. The USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Rare Earths records monazite produced from heavy-mineral-sand concentrates in the south-eastern United States in 2025. The Federal Register notice of 7 November 2025, Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals lists the main host commodities for cerium, lanthanum, neodymium and the other rare earths as “Other rare earths, iron ore, heavy mineral sands (titanium, zirconium)”. It does not name a mineral.
What does the US 2025 critical minerals list include?
The notice. The Federal Register of 7 November 2025 (90 FR 50494) carries the Department of the Interior’s Final 2025 List of Critical Minerals, presented through USGS. It “includes the following 60 minerals”. A script reads those 60 from the notice, and the rare-earth names among them are cerium, dysprosium, erbium, europium, gadolinium, holmium, lanthanum, lutetium, neodymium, praseodymium, samarium, scandium, terbium, thulium, ytterbium and yttrium. Phosphate is listed too: the notice says the Department of Agriculture recommended it, “citing its importance to food security”. Uranium is listed; thorium is not.
For monazite. All five rare-earth elements that head the IMA monazite formulas are listed individually, as are the seven others printed in the Handbook sheets’ analyses: praseodymium, yttrium, dysprosium, holmium, terbium, ytterbium and lutetium. The PO4 is covered by “phosphate” as a commodity. The notice says the list “is not a permanent list but will be dynamic and updated not less than biannually”.
Is monazite on the UK critical minerals list?
The 2024 assessment. The UK 2024 Criticality Assessment (BGS Open Report OR/24/059), produced by the UK Critical Minerals Intelligence Centre and published on 28 November 2024, finds that “34 of the 82 candidate raw materials have a criticality score equal to or greater than 4”. Its Table 1 lists them. Two concern monazite: “Rare earth elements (REEs)” and “Phosphorus (P)”. The report explains that the lanthanoids plus scandium and yttrium “are treated as a single entity in this assessment”, and that phosphate rock was “included in phosphorus (P)”.
Thorium and uranium. Thorium was a candidate but was “excluded due to lack of production and/or trade data”. Uranium was assessed and scored non-critical. The word monazite appears once in the report, in a trade-code description of thorium ores. The report states that it “does not constitute government policy”.
Is monazite a critical raw material in the EU?
The Act. Regulation (EU) 2024/1252, the Critical Raw Materials Act, dated 11 April 2024 in the BGS report’s reference list, has two lists. Annex II, Section 1 names 34 critical raw materials, among them “heavy rare earth elements”, “light rare earth elements”, “phosphate rock” and “phosphorus”. Annex I, Section 1 names 17 strategic raw materials, including “rare earth elements for permanent magnets (Nd, Pr, Tb, Dy, Gd, Sm, and Ce)”. Thorium and uranium appear in neither. The text quoted is the text of Regulation (EU) 2024/1252, the Critical Raw Materials Act (Council PE-CONS 78/23). EUR-Lex returned an empty challenge page to automated fetches.
The scope sentence. Article 4(1) says the raw materials in Annex II count “including in unprocessed form, at any stage of processing and when occurring as a by-product”. Whether a given monazite concentrate falls under that wording is a legal question. This page does not answer it and is not legal advice.
The three-list ledger, worked
Method. The 60 US names were read from the notice’s summary sentence, the 34 UK entries from the report’s Table 1, and the EU’s 17 strategic and 34 critical entries from the Annexes. The script then searched each list for the elements of monazite: every rare-earth oxide printed on the four Handbook monazite sheets (12 elements, five of them heading the IMA formulas), phosphorus, thorium and uranium. It also searched for the word “monazite”. The EU Annex II list was checked against EIT RawMaterials’ saved EUR-Lex print; the 34 entries match one for one.
Result. Monazite is named on 0 of 3 lists. Its 12 rare-earth elements are named individually on the US list (12 of 12) and in the EU Annex I (7 of 12: cerium, praseodymium, neodymium, samarium, gadolinium, terbium and dysprosium), and on the UK list only as a group. Phosphorus is on all three. Thorium is on none. By the same script, “xenotime”, “bastnäsite” (or bastnaesite) and “allanite” appear in none of the three texts either. The BGS news page on the UK list captions apatite as “a phosphorus-bearing mineral”; the mineral is not on the list, its phosphorus is. Xenotime is at xenotime and bastnäsite at bastnäsite. The radioactivity side of monazite is at is monazite radioactive. More guides are in the collecting guides. Nothing on this site is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.