Collecting · Classification

Is tourmaline a beryl?

Is tourmaline a beryl? No. Both are Si6O18 ring silicates, but all 42 IMA tourmalines carry three BO3 groups and no beryllium; beryl is Be3Al2(Si6O18).

Short answer No. Tourmaline is a supergroup of 42 species on the September 2026 IMA list; beryl, the species of aquamarine and emerald, is one species, Be3Al2(Si6O18). They share a six-tetrahedron silicate ring and often a specimen, nothing moreThe ring ledger (IMA, by script) 56 rows print a T6O18 ring. The 42 tourmalines all carry (BO3)3 and none contains Be; 5 rows contain Be with the ring (beryl, bazzite, stoppaniite, pezzottaite-(Cs), johnkoivulaite-(Cs)) and none carries BO3Henry et al. (2011) Tourmaline general formula XY3Z6(T6O18)(BO3)3V3W; the B site “exclusively contains B”Worked composition Beryl 13.96% BeO, no boron. Schorl 9.91%, elbaite 11.15%, dravite 10.89% B2O3, no berylliumCrystal form Beryl hexagonal, point group 6/m 2/m 2/m, prisms. Tourmalines point group 3m, striated ∥ [0001]; schorl and elbaite prominent trigonal prism, commonly hemimorphicHardness Beryl 7.5–8; schorl, elbaite and dravite 7Refractive index Both uniaxial (−). Beryl ω 1.567–1.610; elbaite 1.633–1.651, dravite 1.634–1.661, schorl 1.660–1.671: a gap of 0.023 or more20.00 g piece in water Beryl 12.40–13.27 g; elbaite 13.10–13.55 g, overlapping from 13.10 to 13.27 g; dravite 13.40–13.71 g; schorl 13.71–13.79 gElectrical Schorl, elbaite and dravite sheets: pyroelectric and piezoelectric. The beryl sheet prints neither

No. Tourmaline is a supergroup of 42 borosilicate species on the September 2026 IMA list; beryl is one species, Be3Al2(Si6O18). Both are built on six-tetrahedron silicate rings, which is where the likeness lies: all 42 tourmaline formulas carry three BO3 groups and no beryllium, and beryl is 13.96% BeO with no boron. Hardness 7 against 7.5 to 8.

In short

  • The verdict. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List has a row for beryl, Be3Al2(Si6O18), and none for tourmaline, which is a supergroup: 42 rows share its formula shape by script, the count on the tourmaline page. The Tulane University mineralogy notes on silicate structures (Nelson) name beryl, cordierite and tourmaline together as the common cyclosilicates, rings with a Si:O ratio of 1:3. Same structural family; different minerals.
  • The ring ledger. A script read every IMA formula for a six-tetrahedron ring group, T6O18: 56 rows have one. 42 also carry (BO3)3, the tourmalines, and not one of them contains beryllium. 5 contain beryllium, beryl, bazzite, stoppaniite, pezzottaite-(Cs) and johnkoivulaite-(Cs), and none carries a BO3 group. The ring is shared; in these 56 rows a BO3 group and beryllium never are.
  • The analyses agree. The beryl sheet’s analyses print BeO, 13.46% and 10.79%, and no B2O3; the elbaite, schorl and dravite sheets print B2O3, 10.28%, [10.43]% and 10.32%, and no BeO. Worked from the IMA formulas: beryl 13.96% BeO; schorl 9.91%, elbaite 11.15% and dravite 10.89% B2O3. Henry et al. (2011) say the tourmaline B site exclusively contains boron.
  • Separating them. Beryl is 7.5 to 8, the tourmalines 7. The refractometer is cleaner: beryl’s highest ω is 1.610, elbaite’s lowest 1.633, dravite’s 1.634 and schorl’s 1.660. Schorl and elbaite prisms are trigonal, striated along their length and often different at each end; the tourmaline sheets print pyroelectric and piezoelectric, the beryl sheet neither.
  • Documented failures. The optic sign does not separate them: both are uniaxial (−), unlike phenakite on is phenakite a beryl. The balance fails for elbaite: a 20.00 g piece reads 12.40 to 13.27 g in water as beryl and 13.10 to 13.55 g as elbaite, overlapping from 13.10 to 13.27 g. And colour: the beryl and elbaite sheets both print green, blue, red shades and colourless.
The ring ledger and the hand numbers: beryl against the three commonest tourmaline sheets and cordierite, the third ring silicate the Tulane notes name. IMA formulas from the September 2026 list (by script); BeO and B2O3 by mass worked from the IMA formula on standard atomic weights; Handbook of Mineralogy values as printed; in-water weight of a 20.00 g piece = 20 − 20/D
SpeciesIMA formulaRing groupBO3 groupsBeO / B2O3 by massHardnessDensity (meas.)20.00 g in waterω (sheet); optic sign
BerylBe3Al2(Si6O18)Si6O18013.96% BeO; 0 B2O37.5–82.63–2.9712.40–13.27 g1.567–1.610; (−)
ElbaiteNa(Al1.5Li1.5)Al6(Si6O18)(BO3)3(OH)3(OH)Si6O1830 BeO; 11.15% B2O372.90–3.1013.10–13.55 g1.633–1.651; (−)
DraviteNaMg3Al6(Si6O18)(BO3)3(OH)3(OH)Si6O1830 BeO; 10.89% B2O373.03–3.1813.40–13.71 g1.634–1.661; (−)
SchorlNaFe2+3Al6(Si6O18)(BO3)3(OH)3(OH)Si6O1830 BeO; 9.91% B2O373.18–3.2213.71–13.79 g1.660–1.671; (−)
CordieriteMg2Al3(Si5AlO18)Si5AlO1800 BeO; 0 B2O37–7.52.60–2.6612.31–12.48 gBiaxial; α 1.527–1.560
All 42 tourmaline rowsXY3Z6(T6O18)(BO3)3V3W (Henry et al. 2011)Si6O18 in 39; Si5AlO18 in 2; Si4B2O18 in 13 in all 42Be in 0 of 42————
All 5 Be ring rowsBeryl, bazzite, stoppaniite, pezzottaite-(Cs), johnkoivulaite-(Cs)Si6O18 in all 50 in all 5Be in 5 of 5————

Is tourmaline a beryl? What the IMA list says

No. Beryl is one species on the September 2026 IMA list, Be3Al2(Si6O18), status G. Tourmaline is not a species at all: there is no row for it, and 42 rows share its formula shape, 32 A, 6 Rd, 2 G and 2 Rn, the count on the live tourmaline page. Schorl, elbaite and dravite are three of them. Aquamarine, emerald and morganite are colour varieties of beryl, as is aquamarine a beryl sets out; a green or blue tourmaline is none of them.

Why the question comes up. The Tulane University mineralogy notes on silicate structures (Nelson) group them: “The cyclosilicates are based on rings of SiO4 tetrahedra, with a Si:O ratio of 1:3 The most common minerals based on this structure are Beryl, Cordierite, and Tourmaline.” Both grow in granite pegmatites; the beryl sheet lists tourmaline among its associates, and the elbaite and schorl sheets list beryl. The beryl and elbaite sheets both print green, blue, red shades and colourless, and both minerals form long prisms.

What Henry et al. (2011) add. The tourmaline supergroup has the generalized formula XY3Z6(T6O18)(BO3)3V3W, and “the T site is typically dominated by Si and the B site exclusively contains B”. That B site is the boron triangle, BO3. Beryl has no such site.

The ring ledger: same ring, boron or beryllium

Method. A script read every row of the IMA list and looked for a six-tetrahedron ring group in the formula, written (T6O18) with T silicon, aluminium, boron or phosphorus; then for (BO3)3 and for beryllium. Formulas where the text extraction dropped a superscript, such as oxy-foitite’s, were caught by reading the whole formula column, not splitting on spaces; a first version of the script that split on spaces found 41 tourmalines and missed it.

Result. 56 rows print a T6O18 ring. 42 carry (BO3)3: the tourmalines, 39 with Si6O18, 2 with Si5AlO18 (adachiite, alumino-oxy-rossmanite) and 1 with Si4B2O18 (ertlite). None of the 42 contains beryllium. 5 rows contain beryllium alongside the ring: beryl, bazzite Be3Sc2(Si6O18), stoppaniite Be3Fe3+2(Si6O18), pezzottaite-(Cs) and johnkoivulaite-(Cs). None of the 5 carries a BO3 group. The other 9 ring rows include cordierite, Mg2Al3(Si5AlO18), with neither element.

One edge case. Johnkoivulaite-(Cs), Cs(Be2B)Mg2(Si6O18), has both beryllium and boron, but its boron is written inside a bracket with beryllium, not as a BO3 triangle; the rule this page uses is the BO3 group, not the letter B. Across the list, three rows hold both Be and a BO3 group (berborite, hambergite, mengxianminite), and none of them has a ring.

Tourmaline or beryl in the hand: what separates them

The refractometer. Both are uniaxial negative on their sheets, so the sign does not help. The numbers do: the beryl sheet prints ω 1.567 to 1.610; the elbaite sheet 1.633 to 1.651, dravite 1.634 to 1.661 and schorl 1.660 to 1.671. A reading of 1.610 or below is beryl’s side, 1.633 or above tourmaline’s. Tourmaline’s birefringence is also larger: elbaite 0.018 to 0.021 at matching ends, beryl at most 0.011.

The crystal. Beryl is hexagonal, point group 6/m 2/m 2/m, prisms with {10-10}, {0001} and {11-20}. The schorl, elbaite and dravite sheets give point group 3m and striation along [0001], and the schorl and elbaite sheets a prominent trigonal prism, “commonly hemimorphic”, different at each end; the Tulane notes describe “a rounded triangular cross section”. Tourmaline sheets print pyroelectric and piezoelectric; the beryl sheet does not. Beryl is 7.5 to 8, tourmaline 7: see how to test mineral hardness properly.

Documented failure: the balance. A 20.00 g piece reads 12.40 to 13.27 g in water as beryl, rising with alkali content on its sheet, and 13.10 to 13.55 g as elbaite: the two overlap from 13.10 to 13.27 g. Dravite (13.40 to 13.71 g) and schorl (13.71 to 13.79 g) sit clear of beryl. The method is on how to measure specific gravity at home.

Is tourmaline a mineral, a gemstone, a quartz?

A mineral group, not one mineral. Each of the 42 tourmalines is a mineral species; “tourmaline” is the supergroup name. How a black crystal is named is on is schorl black tourmaline, and how to test material sold as tourmaline on how to tell if tourmaline is real. Hardness 7 on the schorl, elbaite and dravite sheets (7.5 for uvite and liddicoatite, per the tourmaline page) makes it as hard as quartz or slightly harder, which is the answer to “is tourmaline a hard stone”.

Not a quartz, and not an epidote. Quartz is SiO2, with no boron; that test is on is tourmaline a quartz. Epidote is a different group again, on is epidote tourmaline. The other “is it a beryl” pages each have their own test: is euclase a beryl, is chrysoberyl a beryl, is kunzite a beryl and is phenakite a beryl; beryl look-alikes sold as aquamarine are on how to tell if aquamarine is real. None of those tests is repeated here.

Out of scope. Birthstone, precious-stone and buying questions are not answered on this site. More guides are in the collecting guides. We hold no catalogue and nothing here is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.

Questions

Is tourmaline a type of beryl?
No. Beryl is Be3Al2(Si6O18); the 42 tourmalines all carry three BO3 groups and no beryllium. Henry et al. (2011), Nomenclature of the tourmaline-supergroup minerals, American Mineralogist 96, 895 give the tourmaline formula as XY3Z6(T6O18)(BO3)3V3W.
Why are tourmaline and beryl confused?
Both are ring silicates with Si6O18 rings, per the Tulane notes; both grow in pegmatites, appear on each other’s association lines and come as green, blue or red prisms.
How can you tell tourmaline from beryl?
By refractive index: beryl’s ω tops out at 1.610 on the beryl sheet, while elbaite starts at 1.633 and schorl at 1.660. Trigonal, lengthwise-striated prisms point to tourmaline.
Is tourmaline a mineral?
A group of minerals: 42 species on the September 2026 IMA list share its formula, schorl, elbaite and dravite among them.
Does tourmaline contain beryllium?
None of the 42 IMA tourmaline formulas does, and the elbaite sheet’s analysis prints B2O3 10.28% and no BeO.