Ludwigite
Ludwigite, Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3): black fibrous magnesium iron borate, hardness 5–5.5, density 3.80, 5.54% boron; vonsenite series and needles in Pakistani peridot.
Ludwigite is a magnesium iron borate, Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3) on the September 2026 IMA list: black, fibrous, orthorhombic crystals to 20 cm, hardness 5 to 5.5, density 3.80, and 5.54% boron by mass. It forms a series with vonsenite, the ferrous end. GIA calls needle-like ludwigite inclusions diagnostic of Pakistani peridot.
In short
- The species. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List lists ludwigite as Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3), status G, 1874, Romania. The Handbook of Mineralogy sheet writes Mg2Fe3+BO5 in the “Ludwigite group”: orthorhombic, fibrous and curved to 20 cm, tough, hardness 5 to 5.5, density 3.80, pitch-black to olive-black, streak black to greenish black. A 20.00 g piece reads 14.74 g in water.
- The magnesium line. The sheet says ludwigite “Forms a series with vonsenite”, Fe2+2Fe3+O2(BO3) on the IMA list. Recast by script, the Ocna de Fier ludwigite analysis has Mg/(Mg + Fe2+) = 0.956 and the Burguillos vonsenite analysis 0.009: the two analyses sit at the two ends. Worked, ideal ludwigite is 5.54% boron and vonsenite 4.18%.
- Ludwigite in peridot. LeCroy, Gems & Gemology (Summer 2026) writes that “Pakistani peridot is known for its diagnostic ludwigite inclusions”, describing “needle-like ludwigite crystals” in a 7.44 ct stone. Williams and Williams, Gems & Gemology (Spring 2020) say these acicular inclusions are “presumably protogenetic and not oriented consistently” to the host. The sheet lists forsterite among ludwigite’s associates.
- Documented failure: weighing vonsenite. The vonsenite sheet prints density 4.21 measured but 4.80 calculated, 12.3% apart; the cell, worked, gives 4.796. A 20.00 g piece would read 15.25 g or 15.83 g in water depending on which is believed, so the balance cannot place a black fibrous borate on the series; the analysis can.
- Is ludwigite magnetic? The sheet: “Weakly ferromagnetic, probable.” USGS Open-File Report 99-529, Table 1 has no ludwigite row; its vonsenite row reads below 0.01 to 0.60 A, best 0.20 to 0.30, over 3 samples, and magnetite’s best is 0.01 A. The black associate the sheet names first is magnetite.
| Mineral | IMA formula | System (sheet) | Mg/(Mg + Fe2+), worked | Hardness | Density (meas.; calc.) | 20.00 g in water | Streak | Magnetism: sheet; USGS best range, samples |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ludwigite | Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3) | Orthorhombic | 0.956 (Ocna de Fier) | 5–5.5 | 3.80; 3.78 | 14.74 g | Black to greenish black | “Weakly ferromagnetic, probable”; no row |
| Vonsenite | Fe2+2Fe3+O2(BO3) | Orthorhombic | 0.009 (Burguillos) | 5 | 4.21; 4.80 | 15.25 g (meas.); 15.83 g (calc.) | Brownish black | Nothing printed; 0.20–0.30 A, 3 |
| Magnesiohulsite (same IMA formula as ludwigite) | Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3) | Monoclinic | no analysis read | [6] | 4.18; 4.15 | 15.22 g | Dark brown | Nothing printed; no row |
| Hulsite (same IMA formula as vonsenite) | Fe2+2Fe3+O2(BO3) | Monoclinic | no analysis read | about 3 | 4.28–4.57; 4.62 | 15.33–15.62 g | Black | Nothing printed; no row |
| Ilvaite | CaFe3+Fe2+2O(Si2O7)(OH) | Orthorhombic or monoclinic | — | 5.5–6 | 3.99–4.05; 4.064 | 14.99–15.06 g | Black, inclining to green or brown | Nothing printed; 0.30 A, 5 |
| Magnetite | Fe2+Fe3+2O4 | Cubic | — | 5.5–6.5 | 5.175; 5.20 | 16.14 g | Black | “Strongly magnetic”; 0.01 A, 6 |
What is ludwigite? A magnesium iron borate
Ludwigite is Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3) on the September 2026 IMA list, status G, 1874, Romania. The Handbook of Mineralogy ludwigite sheet writes the same atoms as Mg2Fe3+BO5 and places it in the “Ludwigite group”. Worked on standard atomic weights the formula mass is 195.26: boron 5.54%, iron 28.60%, magnesium 24.90%; as oxides, B2O3 17.83%, the figure in the sheet’s ideal column. Other borates on this site are colemanite, ulexite and boracite.
What the sheet records. Orthorhombic, point group 2/m 2/m 2/m, space group Pbam, a = 9.2411, b = 12.2948, c = 3.0213 Å, Z = 4. “Crystals are unterminated, fibrous, curved, to 20 cm; commonly in fanlike to felted aggregates.” Tough; hardness 5 to 5.5; density 3.80 measured, 3.78 calculated, and the cell, worked, gives 3.778. Opaque, translucent only in thin fragments; pitch-black or olive-black; streak black to greenish black; lustre submetallic, and silky. Biaxial (+), pleochroic dark green to dark reddish brown, α 1.83 to 1.85, γ 1.97 to 2.03.
Where it forms. “Typically formed in magnesian iron skarn and contact metamorphic deposits”, with magnetite, forsterite, clinohumite, vonsenite and szaibélyite. The name honours Ernst Ludwig (1842–1915), professor of chemistry at Vienna, “who analyzed the original material”; type material is at the Natural History Museum, Vienna.
Ludwigite or vonsenite? The magnesium line
One series, two names. Both sheets say the two minerals form a series. The IMA list writes ludwigite Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3) and vonsenite Fe2+2Fe3+O2(BO3) (G, 1920, USA): the same frame, with magnesium in one and ferrous iron in the other. Which name applies is a question of which leads, so the decisive number is Mg/(Mg + Fe2+).
Method and result. Each oxide in the two natural analyses was divided by its formula weight and the cations scaled to 5 oxygens. The Ocna de Fier analysis gives Mg 1.910, Fe2+ 0.087, Fe3+ 0.961, B 0.985, reproducing the printed (Mg1.91Fe2+0.09Mn0.01)(Fe3+0.98Al0.02)B1.00O5: Mg/(Mg + Fe2+) = 0.956. The Burguillos, Spain, vonsenite analysis gives Fe2+ 2.027, Mg 0.019, Fe3+ 0.994, B 0.958: 0.009. The two printed analyses are close to the two ends, not in the middle.
Documented failure: the vonsenite density. The vonsenite sheet prints 4.21 measured and 4.80 calculated; worked from its cell, Fe3BO5 gives 4.796, so the calculated figure is consistent and the measured one is 12.3% lower. On the method at how to measure specific gravity at home, 20.00 g of ludwigite reads 14.74 g in water and vonsenite 15.25 g or 15.83 g. Weight suggests where a piece sits; the analysis decides.
What is ludwigite in peridot?
Needle inclusions in Pakistani peridot, per GIA. LeCroy, Gems & Gemology (Summer 2026) describes a 7.44 ct faceted Pakistani peridot with “a fluid-filled cylindrical void among a myriad of needle-like ludwigite crystals”, and writes: “Pakistani peridot is known for its diagnostic ludwigite inclusions”. Williams and Williams, Gems & Gemology (Spring 2020), writing on Burmese star peridot, add that “Pakistani peridot may often feature acicular inclusions of ludwigite”, which they call “presumably protogenetic and not oriented consistently to the crystal structure of the host peridot”.
Read with the sheet. The ludwigite sheet describes fibrous crystals and lists forsterite among its associates in magnesian skarns; peridot is the gem name for forsteritic olivine, set out on is olivine the same as peridot and forsterite. The sheet does not mention peridot or Pakistan, and no fetched source here gives the composition of the needles, so this page does not say where on the magnesium line they fall.
What the sources do not say. Neither GIA note gives a size, a density or an abundance for the needles, and neither ties them to the value of a stone; this page names no market and gives no buying advice. We hold no catalogue and nothing here is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.
Is ludwigite magnetic, and how is it told from ilvaite?
Probably weakly, on its sheet. The physical-properties line ends “Weakly ferromagnetic, probable.” The probable is the sheet’s. USGS Open-File Report 99-529, Table 1 has no ludwigite row; vonsenite’s row reads below 0.01 to 0.60 A in total, best 0.20 to 0.30, over 3 samples, and ilvaite’s 0.10 to 0.50, best 0.30. Magnetite, ludwigite’s first-named associate and “Strongly magnetic” on its sheet, is best at 0.01. The magnet questions are gathered on which minerals are magnetic.
Same formula, different mineral. A script over the IMA list finds magnesiohulsite written exactly Mg2Fe3+O2(BO3), as ludwigite is, and hulsite exactly Fe2+2Fe3+O2(BO3), as vonsenite is. The sheets separate them by system: ludwigite and vonsenite orthorhombic, magnesiohulsite and hulsite monoclinic; hulsite is hardness about 3. Chemistry alone does not name a ludwigite.
Ilvaite. One reference on the ludwigite sheet is titled “Members of the ludwigite–vonsenite series and their distinction from ilvaite” (Leonard and others, 1962). Ilvaite is a calcium iron silicate, CaFe3+Fe2+2O(Si2O7)(OH), hardness 5.5 to 6, density 3.99 to 4.05; it carries silicon and calcium and no boron, which an analysis shows at once.
Where is ludwigite found?
Distribution, as printed. “Numerous localities, some with large amounts.” The sheet names the Iuliana mine, Ocna de Fier (Morávicza; Vaskő), Romania; the Brosso mine, near Ivrea, Italy; Broadford, Isle of Skye, Scotland; the Nordmark district, Värmland, Sweden; the Tazheran massif west of Lake Baikal and “large crystals from Titovskoye, Sakha”, Russia; the Gole Gohar iron deposit, Iran; the Pomeroy mine, Anaconda, and Philipsburg, Montana; the Crestmore quarry, California; the Mountain Lake mine, Utah; the York River tactite zone, Ontario, and the Cross quarry near Wakefield, Quebec; and the Hol Kol mine, North Korea.
Type locality. The sheet has no type-locality line. One of its references is titled “Ludwigite from the type locality, Ocna de Fier, Romania” (Marincea, 1999), and the IMA list gives Romania; that is the extent of what is printed. See what is a type locality. The rest of the reference section is at the species index.