Collecting · Identification

Is malachite a carbonate?

Yes: malachite is Cu2(CO3)(OH)2, a copper carbonate, 57.48% copper, hardness 3.5–4. Why copper plus carbon is not enough: the CO3 test on nine IMA rows.

Short answer Yes. Malachite is Cu2(CO3)(OH)2 on the IMA list and its Handbook sheet: a carbonate group and two hydroxyls with copper. geology.com gives its chemical classification as CarbonateIMA row Cu2(CO3)(OH)2; status G (grandfathered); year printed as ?; country unknown. A mineral species, crystals to 9 cmElements by mass, worked Cu 57.48%, C 5.43%, O 36.18%, H 0.91%; as oxides CuO 71.95, CO2 19.90, H2O 8.15, the sheet’s ideal columnThe CO3 test Nine IMA rows are built only of copper, carbon, oxygen and hydrogen. Four carry CO3: malachite, azurite, georgeite, marklite. Five hold carbon as oxalate, acetate or C2H3O3Copper per carbonate Malachite 2, azurite 1.5, marklite 2.5; georgeite variable by its formulaHardness, density, streak (sheet) Hardness 3.5–4; density 4.05; streak pale green; cleavage perfect on {−201}; a 20.00 g piece reads 15.06 g in waterMineral, rock or metal? A mineral with its own IMA row. Massive malachite is still the mineral. Not a metal: native copper is the metalA gemstone? The sheet uses no gem wording; geology.com says it has been used as a gemstone and sculptural material for thousands of years

Yes. Malachite is Cu2(CO3)(OH)2 on the September 2026 IMA list: a copper carbonate with hydroxyl, 57.48% copper by mass, hardness 3.5 to 4, density 4.05. Of nine IMA rows built only of copper, carbon, oxygen and hydrogen, four carry the CO3 group; the other five hold their carbon as oxalate, acetate or C2H3O3 and are not carbonates.

In short

  • The verdict. Malachite is a carbonate. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List writes Cu2(CO3)(OH)2, status G; the Handbook of Mineralogy sheet writes the same and calls it “A common secondary mineral formed in the oxidation zone of copper deposits”. The geology.com malachite article calls it “a green copper carbonate hydroxide mineral” and classifies it as Carbonate. Worked, it is 57.48% copper, as on malachite, is malachite toxic and is copper a mineral.
  • The CO3 test. Two script methods over the IMA list find 32 rows with both copper and CO3; 28 of them also contain some other element. Nine rows are built of Cu, C, O and H alone; four of them carry the CO3 group: malachite, azurite, georgeite and marklite. Copper per carbonate runs 2 in malachite, 1.5 in azurite and 2.5 in marklite.
  • Documented failure: copper plus carbon is not a carbonate. The other five Cu–C–O–H rows hold carbon in other groups: fiemmeite, middlebackite and moolooite as C2O4 (oxalate), hoganite as acetate, CH3COO, and lazaraskeite as C2H3O3. They contain the same four elements as malachite and none is a carbonate. The class follows the anion group, not the element list.
  • Documented failure: green copper is not a carbonate. Of the seven green copper look-alikes tabled on the malachite species page, only rosasite and aurichalcite are carbonates. Pseudomalachite and libethenite are phosphates, brochantite a sulfate, atacamite a chloride hydroxide and dioptase a silicate. Brochantite shares malachite’s pale green streak and hardness 3.5–4.
  • The other questions. A mineral, not a rock or a metal: it has its own IMA row, and native copper is the metal. Crystals reach 9 cm; most is botryoidal. Azurite, Cu3(CO3)2(OH)2, is the other copper carbonate, 55.31% copper; health questions about either go to is azurite toxic and is malachite toxic, and this is not advice.
The CO3 test: every row on the September 2026 IMA list whose formula is built of copper, carbon, oxygen and hydrogen only (9 rows, script over refcache/ima.txt), sorted by the group that holds the carbon. Copper by mass worked on standard atomic weights for fixed formulas; Handbook of Mineralogy sheet values for the two cached here (malachite, azurite); a dash means no sheet was read for this page. In-water weight of a 20.00 g piece = 20 − 20/D
MineralIMA formula; statusCarbon held asA carbonate?Cu by massCu per carbon groupSheet: colour, hardness, density, 20.00 g in water
MalachiteCu2(CO3)(OH)2; G, ?, unknownCO3Yes57.48%2 per CO3Bright, dark or blackish green, commonly banded in masses; 3.5–4; 4.05; 15.06 g
AzuriteCu3(CO3)2(OH)2; G, 1824, FranceCO3Yes55.31%1.5 per CO3Azure-blue, Berlin blue, very dark to pale blue; 3.5–4; 3.773; 14.70 g
MarkliteCu5(CO3)2(OH)6·6H2O; A, 2015-101, GermanyCO3Yes49.04%2.5 per CO3—
Georgeite[Cu(OH)2-x(H2O)x][CO3]x/2; Rd, 2023 s.p., AustraliaCO3YesVariable (x)Variable—
MiddlebackiteCu2C2O4(OH)2; A, 2015-115, AustraliaC2O4 (oxalate)No51.02%2 per C2O4—
FiemmeiteCu2(C2O4)(OH)2(H2O)2; A, 2017-115, ItalyC2O4 (oxalate)No44.57%2 per C2O4—
MoolooiteCu(C2O4)·nH2O; A, 1980-082, AustraliaC2O4 (oxalate)NoVaries with n (41.93% at n = 0)1 per C2O4—
HoganiteCu(CH3COO)2(H2O); A, 2001-029, AustraliaCH3COO (acetate)No31.83%0.5 per CH3COO—
LazaraskeiteCu(C2H3O3)2; A, 2018-137, USAC2H3O3No29.75%0.5 per C2H3O3—
All 9Cu, C, O, H only4 CO3; 5 other4 yes, 5 no29.75–57.48% (fixed formulas)——
Wider net32 IMA rows contain both Cu and CO3CO3Yes, all 32——28 also contain another element besides Cu, C, O and H

Is malachite a carbonate? What the formula says

Yes: a carbonate with hydroxyl. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List lists malachite as Cu2(CO3)(OH)2, status G (grandfathered), with the year printed as a question mark and the country unknown. The Handbook of Mineralogy malachite sheet writes the same formula, and its references include Süsse (1967) and Zigan and others (1977), two refinements of the malachite structure. Two copper atoms, one CO3 group and two OH groups: the carbon sits in a carbonate group, so the mineral is a carbonate, and because hydroxyl sits beside it, a carbonate hydroxide. The geology.com malachite article says the same in words: “a green copper carbonate hydroxide mineral”, chemical classification Carbonate.

Worked composition. With Cu 63.546, C 12.011, O 15.999 and H 1.008 the formula mass is 221.11: 57.48% copper, 5.43% carbon, 36.18% oxygen and 0.91% hydrogen. As oxides that is CuO 71.95, CO2 19.90 and H2O 8.15, the sheet’s ideal column exactly. Those are the figures on malachite; its Elba recast and banding rule are not repeated here. The class question for a zinc carbonate is on is smithsonite a carbonate and for a calcium carbonate on is calcite a silicate; their ledgers are not repeated either.

Copper and carbon are not enough: the CO3 test

Method. A script read the formula column of the September 2026 IMA list, with page-break characters stripped, and kept every row whose formula contains copper and CO3: 31 rows parse directly and a 32nd, ramazzoite, wraps onto a second line, where a token scan of the whole text finds it. A second filter kept the rows whose formula is built of Cu, C, O and H and no other element: nine. The count is of formula shape on one list.

Result. Four of the nine carry the CO3 group and are carbonates: malachite, Cu2(CO3)(OH)2; azurite, Cu3(CO3)2(OH)2; marklite, Cu5(CO3)2(OH)6·6H2O; and georgeite, [Cu(OH)2-x(H2O)x][CO3]x/2, whose carbonate share varies with x. Copper per carbonate group is 2 for malachite, 1.5 for azurite and 2.5 for marklite. Of the fixed formulas, malachite has the highest copper share of the nine, 57.48%, then azurite at 55.31%.

Documented failure: five rows with the same elements and a different class. Middlebackite, Cu2C2O4(OH)2, fiemmeite, Cu2(C2O4)(OH)2(H2O)2, and moolooite, Cu(C2O4)·nH2O, hold carbon as C2O4, oxalate; hoganite, Cu(CH3COO)2(H2O), as acetate; lazaraskeite as C2H3O3. A list of elements cannot tell malachite from middlebackite, which also has two coppers and two hydroxyls per carbon group; the formula can, with one carbon per two coppers in malachite and two in middlebackite, bonded as C2O4. The group decides, as the sulfate question does on is jarosite a sulfate and is anglesite a sulfate.

Is every green copper mineral a carbonate?

No. Documented failure: green and copper. The live malachite page tables seven green copper look-alikes from their sheets. By their IMA formulas only two are carbonates: rosasite, CuZn(CO3)(OH)2, and aurichalcite, (Zn,Cu)5(CO3)2(OH)6. Pseudomalachite, Cu5(PO4)2(OH)4, and libethenite, Cu2(PO4)(OH), are phosphates; brochantite, Cu4(SO4)(OH)6, is a sulfate; atacamite, Cu2Cl(OH)3, a chloride hydroxide; dioptase a silicate.

Where the hand tests overlap. Brochantite prints the same pale green streak as malachite and the same hardness, 3.5 to 4; a 20.00 g piece reads 14.96 g in water against malachite’s 15.06 g, 0.10 g apart. Pseudomalachite, named for the resemblance, reads 15.18 to 15.40 g. The banding rule on malachite and the density test on how to tell if malachite is real are the identification tools; this page does not repeat them and gives no chemical test. Chrysocolla, a silicate, is separated on is chrysocolla the same as malachite.

Is malachite a mineral, a rock, a gemstone or a metal?

A mineral. It has its own IMA row and, by Nickel 1995, Definition of a mineral (Mineralogical Magazine 59, 767), “a mineral is an element or chemical compound that is normally crystalline and which has been formed as a result of geological processes”. Crystals are acicular to prismatic, thick tabular or equant, to 9 cm, but the sheet says it is “typically stalactitic, mammillary, botryoidal”, radially fibrous inside; see what does botryoidal mean. A rock? No: a banded botryoidal mass is still one mineral; the crystal-and-mineral distinction is on crystal vs mineral: what is the difference.

A gemstone? The Handbook sheet uses no gem wording. The geology.com article says it “has been used as a gemstone and sculptural material for thousands of years” and that its use as gem and ornamental stone is limited by its perfect cleavage and hardness of 3.5 to 4; this page does not grade it. A metal? No. Malachite contains a metal, copper, at 57.48% by mass, but is a compound; the metal is native copper, Cu, as worked on is copper a mineral. Why a polished piece goes dull is on why is my malachite dull; the magnet question on is malachite magnetic.

Malachite and azurite. Both are copper carbonates with hydroxyl and each sheet names the other as an associate. The geology.com article lists azurite first among malachite’s associated minerals too. Azurite is 55.31% copper and reads 14.70 g in water for 20.00 g; hazard questions about it are on is azurite toxic and about malachite on is malachite toxic. This page is not health or safety advice. More guides are in the collecting guides. Nothing on this site is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.

Questions

Is malachite a carbonate mineral?
Yes: Cu2(CO3)(OH)2 on the IMA list and its Handbook sheet, a copper carbonate with hydroxyl, 57.48% copper. The geology.com malachite article gives its chemical classification as Carbonate.
Is malachite a carbonate or a hydroxide?
Both groups are in the formula: one CO3 and two OH per two copper atoms. It is classed as a carbonate, a carbonate hydroxide in full, as azurite is.
Is malachite a mineral or a rock?
A mineral, with its own IMA row, status G. A banded botryoidal mass is still malachite; its Handbook sheet records crystals to 9 cm as well.
Is malachite a metal?
No. It is a copper compound, 57.48% copper by mass. Native copper, Cu, is the metal and has its own IMA row.
What other copper carbonates are there?
Azurite, Cu3(CO3)2(OH)2, 55.31% copper, and on the IMA list marklite and georgeite, plus mixed-metal ones such as rosasite and aurichalcite.