Is pyrite a metal?
No: pyrite is FeS2, iron sulfide, 53.45% sulfur. Its lustre is metallic but its sheet prints it brittle and a semiconductor. The tenacity ledger over 87 sheets.
No. Pyrite is FeS2, iron sulfide, 46.55% iron and 53.45% sulfur by mass: a compound, not a metal. Its lustre is metallic, but its Handbook sheet prints it brittle, hardness 6 to 6.5, and “a semiconductor”. Of 87 cached metallic-lustre sheets that print a tenacity, the 8 malleable or ductile ones, native iron and gold among them, contain no sulfur.
In short
- The verdict. Pyrite is not a metal. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List writes it FeS2, status G; the Handbook of Mineralogy sheet writes the same and calls it “The most abundant and widespread sulfide.” Worked, FeS2 is 46.55% iron and 53.45% sulfur, the figures on pyrite. The Cambridge Dictionary defines a metal as a chemical element or a mixture of such elements; pyrite is a compound, two sulfurs to each iron.
- Metallic is a lustre, not a class. The sheet prints “Metallic, splendent”. The geology.com article on luster says a metallic luster means the reflectivity and brightness of a metal, always opaque, and names pyrite, galena, chalcopyrite and pyrrhotite as sulfides that have one. The same sheet says pyrite is “a semiconductor”: of the 668 sheets cached here it is the only one to use the word.
- The tenacity ledger. A script read the Luster and Tenacity fields of every cached sheet. 141 print a metallic lustre; 87 of those print a tenacity. 8 say malleable or ductile, and none contains sulfur or oxygen: copper, gold, silver, iron, platinum, palladium, iridium and hongshiite, PtCu. 65, pyrite among them, say only brittle.
- Documented failure: hardness points the wrong way. Pyrite, at 6 to 6.5, is harder than native iron (4), copper, gold and silver (2.5 to 3), platinum (4 to 4.5) and palladium (4.5 to 5); only iridium, 6 to 7, matches it. A hard, shining, heavy mineral is not thereby a metal. And lustre fails both ways: graphite, carbon, prints metallic and sectile; acanthite, Ag2S, is sectile and is a sulfide.
- The other questions. A mineral: its own IMA row. Not an element: two. A crystal: cubes, pyritohedra and octahedra to 25 cm or more. A sulfide: yes. An iron ore? The geology.com pyrite article says it is not an important source of iron or sulfur today. Gold or not is on what is fool’s gold; hazard questions go to toxic minerals in a collection, not advice.
| Mineral | IMA formula | Element or compound? | Lustre, as printed | Tenacity, as printed | Hardness | Density (meas.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrite | FeS2 | Compound: Fe and S | Metallic, splendent | Brittle (and “a semiconductor”) | 6–6.5 | 5.018 |
| Iron (native) | Fe | Element | Metallic | Malleable | 4 | 7.3–7.87 |
| Copper (native) | Cu | Element | Metallic | Highly malleable and ductile | 2.5–3 | 8.95 |
| Gold | Au | Element | Metallic | Very malleable and ductile | 2.5–3 | 19.3 |
| Silver | Ag | Element | Metallic | Ductile, malleable | 2.5–3 | 10.1–11.1 |
| Platinum | Pt | Element | Metallic | Malleable and ductile | 4–4.5 | 14–19 |
| Iridium | Ir (sheet: (Ir,Os,Ru)) | Element; alloy on the sheet | Very high metallic | Somewhat malleable | 6–7 | 22.65–22.84 |
| Marcasite (the other FeS2) | FeS2 | Compound | Metallic | Brittle | 6–6.5 | 4.887 |
| Galena (associate) | PbS | Compound | Metallic | Brittle | 2.5–2.75 | 7.58 |
| Chalcocite | Cu2S | Compound | Metallic | Brittle, somewhat sectile | 2.5–3 | 5.5–5.8 |
| Acanthite | Ag2S | Compound | Metallic | Sectile | 2.0–2.5 | 7.20–7.22 |
| Graphite | C | Element | Metallic; may be dull, earthy | Flexible but not elastic; sectile | 1–2 | 2.09–2.23 |
| All 87 with a tenacity | — | — | Metallic | 8 malleable or ductile; 11 sectile; 65 brittle only; 3 other | — | — |
| The 8 malleable or ductile | Cu, Au, Ag, Fe, Pt, Pd, Ir, PtCu | Single elements, or platinum-group elements (with Cu in hongshiite); no S or O | Metallic | Malleable or ductile | 2.5–7 | 7.3–22.84 |
Is pyrite a metal? What the formula and the definition say
No: a compound of a metal with sulfur. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List lists pyrite as FeS2, status G (grandfathered), with no year and the country unknown; marcasite is the other FeS2 row. The Handbook of Mineralogy pyrite sheet writes FeS2, places it in the pyrite group, dimorphous with marcasite, and opens its Distribution field “The most abundant and widespread sulfide.” With Fe 55.845 and S 32.06 the formula mass is 119.97: 46.55% iron and 53.45% sulfur, and two of every three atoms are sulfur. The Elba analysis, Fe 46.49 and S 53.49, gives 2.004 sulfur per iron.
The definition. The Cambridge Dictionary defines a metal as “a chemical element, such as iron or gold, or a mixture of such elements, such as steel, that is generally hard and strong, and through which electricity and heat can travel”. Pyrite is neither an element nor a mixture: it is a chemical compound with a fixed ratio, which is what Nickel 1995, Definition of a mineral (Mineralogical Magazine 59, 767) allows a mineral to be. Iron is a metal; pyrite contains iron, as malachite contains copper, and is not one.
What the sheet says about conduction. The Physical Properties field ends “a semiconductor”. That is the sheet’s word for its electrical behaviour; it gives no figure, and this page adds none. A script searched every one of the 668 sheets cached here for “semiconductor” and found it on pyrite’s alone.
Why does pyrite look metallic? Lustre is appearance
Lustre describes light, not composition. The geology.com article on luster says that specimens with a metallic luster “exhibit the reflectivity and brightness of a metal and are always opaque”, and that “Many sulfide and sulfosalt minerals have a metallic luster, such as pyrite, galena, chalcopyrite, and pyrrhotite.” It adds that the name nonmetallic “applies to the luster of these minerals and has nothing to do with their elemental composition.” The pyrite sheet prints “Metallic, splendent” and opaque, pale brass-yellow, tarnishing darker and iridescent.
Where this has been worked before. Which sulfides print a metallic lustre at all is the lustre ledger on is sphalerite a sulfide, 62 of 80 sulfide sheets; it is not repeated here. The question on this page is the other one: of the minerals that look metallic, which behave like a metal when struck? Why a pyrite looks silver rather than brass is on why is my pyrite silver.
Metal or metallic? The tenacity ledger
Method. A script read every Handbook sheet cached for this site, 668 on the list frozen on 18 November 2026. 61 print no Luster field. 141 use the word metallic in it, not counting submetallic alone; 87 of those also print a Tenacity field. Each tenacity was sorted once, in order: malleable or ductile; otherwise sectile; otherwise brittle. Gold and copper were the positive controls for malleable, pyrite and galena for brittle. None of the search words contains a ligature.
Result. 8 say malleable or ductile: native copper (“Highly malleable and ductile”), gold, silver, iron (“Malleable”), platinum, palladium, iridium (“Somewhat malleable”) and hongshiite, PtCu (“Brittle, somewhat ductile and malleable”). Each is a single element or, for iridium and hongshiite, platinum-group metals with copper, and none contains sulfur or oxygen. 11 are sectile, including acanthite, chalcocite and graphite. 65 say brittle only: pyrite, marcasite, galena, hematite, magnetite, arsenopyrite and tenorite among them. Three print n.d. or other words.
Documented failure: the shine. All 87 look metallic and only 8 behave as metals on the sheets. Graphite, carbon, is a single element, prints a metallic lustre and is flexible and sectile, not malleable; acanthite, silver sulfide, is sectile and a sulfide. Tenacity is a property to read on the sheet, not a test this page asks anyone to perform; the gold-or-pyrite pin test is on what is fool’s gold and is not repeated.
Is pyrite iron? Pyrite against native iron
Two minerals. Native iron has its own IMA row, Fe, status G. The Handbook of Mineralogy iron sheet gives cubic, “Typically in small blebs but also in masses up to 25 tons; crystals rare”, tenacity malleable, hardness 4, density 7.3 to 7.87, steel-grey to iron-black, metallic, and lists pyrite first among its associates. Its Cameron, Missouri, analysis is 99.16% iron. Pyrite is brittle, hardness 6 to 6.5 and density 5.018: native iron is up to 1.57 times as dense and two or more Mohs steps softer.
Documented failure: hardness. The Cambridge definition calls metals generally hard and strong, but on these sheets pyrite is harder than native iron, copper, gold, silver, platinum and palladium; only iridium, 6 to 7, matches it. Hardness does not make pyrite a metal, and softness does not make gold one; the scratch method is on how to test mineral hardness properly.
An ore of iron? The geology.com pyrite article says pyrite “is composed of iron and sulfur; however, the mineral does not serve as an important source of either of these elements”, and that iron is typically obtained from oxide ores such as hematite and magnetite. It adds that pyrite used to be an important ore for the production of sulfur and sulfuric acid. Worked, 2.148 kg of pyrite holds 1 kg of iron.
Is pyrite a mineral, an element, a crystal or a sulfide?
A mineral. It has its own IMA row; the general test is on is quartz a mineral. An element? No: two elements, iron and sulfur, in a fixed one-to-two ratio. A crystal? Yes, often: the sheet records cubes, pyritohedra, octahedra and combinations, striated, to 25 cm or more, as well as granular, framboidal and stalactitic forms; see crystal vs mineral: what is the difference. A sulfide? Yes: the sheet calls it the most abundant and widespread one, and geology.com gives its chemical classification as Sulfide. The copper iron sulfide is on is chalcopyrite a sulfide.
Pyrite and its look-alikes. Telling pyrite from gold and chalcopyrite is the three-step rule on pyrite; from marcasite, the Vickers gap on is marcasite the same as pyrite; from glass and imitations, how to tell if pyrite is real; crumbling specimens, why is my pyrite crumbling. None is repeated here. Hazard questions about sulfide minerals go to toxic minerals in a collection; this page is not health or safety advice. More guides are in the collecting guides. Nothing on this site is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.