Is kyanite a quartz?
Is kyanite a quartz? No. Kyanite, Al2OSiO4, is an island silicate whose SiO4 groups share no corners; in quartz, SiO2, every tetrahedron shares all four.
No. Kyanite is aluminium silicate, Al2OSiO4 on the IMA list; quartz is silicon dioxide, SiO2. In kyanite each SiO4 tetrahedron stands alone and shares no corner with another; in quartz every tetrahedron shares all four. Kyanite can match quartz’s hardness 7 across its blade, but a 20.00 g piece reads 14.33 g or more in water against quartz’s 12.45 g.
In short
- The verdict. The September 2026 IMA-CNMNC Master List has separate rows: kyanite Al2OSiO4 and quartz SiO2. The Tulane University mineralogy notes on silicate structures (Nelson) class kyanite with the island silicates, “Among these are the olivines, garnets, Al2SiO5 minerals”, whose tetrahedra share no corners, and quartz with the framework silicates, where “all of the corner oxygens are shared”. Kyanite is 17.33% silicon by mass, quartz 46.74%.
- The shared-corner count. Each corner shared between two tetrahedra counts half to each, so a tetrahedron sharing n corners owns 4 − n/2 oxygens, and n = 8 − 2 × (O per tetrahedral cation). Read off the silicate group the IMA list prints: kyanite’s SiO4 gives 0, quartz’s SiO2 gives 4. They are the two ends of the scale.
- The ladder between. Worked the same way on other species with pages here: topaz SiO4, 0; hemimorphite Si2O7, 1; beryl Si6O18, 2; diopside Si2O6, 2; muscovite (Si3Al)O10, 3; albite (AlSi3)O8, 4. Each matches the class the Tulane notes give for that structure type, and kyanite sits with topaz at the bottom.
- Documented failure. andalusite and sillimanite are written Al2SiO5 on the IMA list, and the count read blindly off that gives −2, an impossible number: the fifth oxygen is not part of the silicate group. The IMA writes kyanite Al2OSiO4, which separates it. Tremolite’s Si8O22 gives 2.5 where Tulane’s double-chain sentence says each tetrahedron shares 3; this page prints both.
- In the hand. Hardness fails: kyanite is 7 across its blade, like quartz. The balance and the refractometer work: 14.33 to 14.52 g in water against 12.45 g for a 20.00 g piece, and indices from 1.710 against at most 1.553. Kyanite’s perfect {100} cleavage and bent blades are the visual tell; quartz’s cleavage is rarely observable.
| Mineral | IMA formula | Silicate group as written | O per tetrahedral cation | Corners shared, n | Tulane class for that group | Agrees? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kyanite | Al2OSiO4 | SiO4 | 4 | 0 | Nesosilicate (island); Al2SiO5 minerals named | Yes |
| Topaz | Al2SiO4F2 | SiO4 | 4 | 0 | Nesosilicate (island) | Yes |
| Hemimorphite | Zn4(Si2O7)(OH)2·H2O | Si2O7 | 3.5 | 1 | Sorosilicate (double island), hemimorphite named | Yes |
| Beryl | Be3Al2(Si6O18) | Si6O18 | 3 | 2 | Cyclosilicate (ring), beryl named | Yes |
| Diopside | CaMgSi2O6 | Si2O6 | 3 | 2 | Inosilicate, single chain (pyroxenes) | Yes |
| Tremolite | ☐Ca2(Mg5.0-4.5Fe2+0.0-0.5)Si8O22(OH)2 | Si8O22 | 2.75 | 2.5 | Inosilicate, double chain: “each tetrahedral group shares 3” | Partly: an average |
| Muscovite | KAl2(Si3Al)O10(OH)2 | (Si3Al)O10 | 2.5 | 3 | Phyllosilicate (sheet), micas named | Yes |
| Albite | Na(AlSi3O8) | (AlSi3)O8 | 2 | 4 | Tectosilicate (framework), Al replacing Si | Yes |
| Quartz | SiO2 | SiO2 | 2 | 4 | Tectosilicate (framework), quartz named | Yes |
| Andalusite, sillimanite | Al2SiO5 | SiO5 if read blindly | 5 | −2 | Nesosilicate (Al2SiO5 minerals named) | No: documented failure |
Is kyanite a quartz? What the formulas say
No: two species. The September 2026 IMA list gives kyanite its own row, Al2OSiO4, status A, 1967 s.p., Austria, and quartz its own, SiO2, A, 1967 s.p. A script finds 3 rows written Al2SiO5 or Al2OSiO4, kyanite, andalusite and sillimanite, the trimorphs the Handbook kyanite sheet names, and 8 rows written SiO2, quartz among them. Kyanite has aluminium; quartz has none.
What the sheets print. Kyanite: triclinic, crystals bladed and tabular on {100}, elongated along [001], to 0.5 m, typically bent or twisted; cleavage perfect on {100}, good on {010}; hardness 5.5 ∥ [001] and 7 ∥ [100]; density 3.53 to 3.65; blue, white, rarely green, gray, yellow, pink or black; biaxial (−), α 1.710 to 1.718, γ 1.724 to 1.734. The Elovyi analysis recasts by script to Al 2.01 and Si 0.99 per 5 oxygens. Quartz: hexagonal, hardness 7, density 2.65, cleavage rarely observable, uniaxial (+), ω 1.544, ε 1.553.
Agreement with the live pages. The feldspar question is on is kyanite a feldspar, with its alkali–alumina check and the 14.33 g kyanite reading this page shares; fluorescence is on is kyanite UV reactive. The other “is it a quartz” pages answer with indices, names and element checks, is topaz a quartz and is fluorite a quartz among them; none of their tests is repeated here. The mineral-or-not test is on is quartz a mineral.
The shared-corner count: reading a silicate from its formula
The idea, from the Tulane notes. Silicates are built from SiO4 tetrahedra, and “only corner oxygens will be shared with other SiO4 groups”. If no corner is shared, “each tetrahedron will be isolated”: the nesosilicates, or island silicates. If all are shared, “a framework structure develops. The basic structural group then becomes SiO2. The minerals quartz, cristobalite, and tridymite all are based on this structure.” Between lie double islands (Si2O7), rings (Si6O18, beryl the example), single chains (SiO3 or Si2O6, the pyroxenes), double chains (Si4O11, the amphiboles) and sheets (Si2O5, the micas).
The arithmetic. A shared oxygen belongs half to each tetrahedron. One that shares n corners therefore owns 4 − n/2 oxygens, so n = 8 − 2 × (O per tetrahedral cation). Kyanite’s SiO4 has 4 oxygens per silicon: n = 0. Quartz’s SiO2 has 2: n = 4. The script gives 1 for hemimorphite’s Si2O7, 2 for beryl’s Si6O18 and diopside’s Si2O6, 3 for muscovite’s (Si3Al)O10 and 4 for albite’s (AlSi3)O8. Each agrees with the class Tulane gives that kind of structure.
What it says about kyanite. Kyanite is at the bottom of the ladder and quartz at the top: the two are as far apart as silicates can be in how their tetrahedra link. That is also why kyanite carries only 37.08% SiO2 by mass, where quartz is 100%; the rest of kyanite is alumina, 62.92%.
Where the count fails: andalusite, sillimanite and tremolite
Documented failure: the fifth oxygen. The IMA list writes andalusite and sillimanite as Al2SiO5. Read naively, that is 5 oxygens per silicon and n = −2, which is impossible: one oxygen in Al2SiO5 is not bonded to silicon at all. The count only works on the silicate group, and the formula has to show it. The IMA writes kyanite Al2OSiO4, splitting off that oxygen, and topaz Al2SiO4F2, which is why both read 0. Tulane puts all three Al2SiO5 minerals among the nesosilicates.
A partial fit: double chains. Tremolite’s Si8O22 gives 2.75 oxygens per silicon and n = 2.5. The Tulane notes say that in double chains “each tetrahedral group shares 3 of its oxygens”. The formula’s 2.5 is an average over the chain; the notes’ sentence and the arithmetic do not match, and this page prints both rather than resolving them.
Not a field test. The count reads a formula; it is not a measurement anyone can make on a specimen. It says what kind of silicate kyanite is, not how to identify one; for that, the next section.
Kyanite or quartz in the hand: what separates them
They grow together. The kyanite sheet’s occurrence line reads “In gneisses, schists, included pegmatites, and quartz veins”, and the International Gem Society kyanite article lists quartz among kyanite’s inclusions and pictures kyanites in a quartz matrix. So the question on a specimen is usually which part is which.
Hardness fails. Kyanite is 5.5 along the blade and 7 across it. Across the blade it is as hard as quartz, so a scratch test can call kyanite quartz; along it kyanite is softer, at 5.5. How to run it fairly is on how to test mineral hardness properly.
Weight and index work. Measured densities of 3.53 to 3.65 against 2.65 mean a clean 20.00 g piece reads 14.33 to 14.52 g in water as kyanite and 12.45 g as quartz, 1.88 g apart; the method is on how to measure specific gravity at home. Kyanite’s lowest index, 1.710, is 0.157 above quartz’s highest, 1.553. And kyanite’s perfect {100} cleavage, its vitreous to pearly lustre and its bent, twisted blades are things quartz, with cleavage rarely observable and a conchoidal fracture, does not show.
Is kyanite a gemstone, a crystal or a rock?
A mineral and a silicate. Kyanite is a mineral with its own IMA row, and an aluminium silicate. It forms crystals, bladed, to 0.5 m on its sheet; the general distinction is on crystal vs mineral: what is the difference.
Not a metamorphic rock. It is a mineral found in metamorphic rocks: the sheet says it forms “from moderately high-pressure regional metamorphism of principally pelitic rocks” and is also detrital in sedimentary rocks. staurolite, andalusite and sillimanite are among its associates.
A gemstone? The International Gem Society kyanite article calls kyanite “notoriously difficult to facet because of its perfect cleavage and variable hardness” but “a popular collector’s gem”. Whether kyanite is asbestos or a health hazard is not answered here; those questions go to toxic minerals in a collection, and nothing on this page is health or safety advice. More guides are in the collecting guides. We hold no catalogue and nothing here is offered for sale; the wanted list is the only commercial route.